Pizza restaurants

Tom & Nancy's Pizza

4.2 119 reviews 3:00 AM - 8:00 PM 423 Stone Rd, Rochester, NY 14616, United States

Discover this place

Tom & Nancy's Pizza, located at 423 Stone Rd in Rochester, NY, garners rave reviews for its remarkable dedication to craft and quality. Patrons like Betty Hamm laud the establishment for taking no shortcuts, showcasing an exquisite pizza that speaks to years of experience. Customers appreciate the thoughtful touch of small-sized pizzas, ideal for solo dining or satisfying lunch leftovers, as highlighted by Mark Nicastro.

Their thin crust cheese and pepperoni are perfectly executed, with sauce that harmonizes beautifully across every bite, according to Ed Starowicz. It's clear that the vow to maintain high standards resonates well with visitors, creating an inviting atmosphere that Scott Stewart emphasizes, especially with friendly service and a clean environment.

Longtime fans, like laura lovestocraft, find nostalgia and joy as they revisit the flavors they cherished decades ago. With a rich history and a menu that delights the senses, Tom & Nancy's Pizza is not just a local spot; it's a culinary landmark that promises satisfaction with every slice. Don't miss the chance to indulge in this exceptional culinary experience.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Tom & Nancy's Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Tom & Nancy's Pizza

4.2

119 reviews

100%

23%

12%

15%

Review highlights

Based on 119 reviews

Tom & Nancy's Pizza in Rochester is widely praised for its authentic, high-quality pizza made with care and expertise, reflecting decades of experience. Customers appreciate the availability of smaller pizza sizes, ideal for individual meals with potential leftovers. The thin crust and flavorful sauce consistently receive positive remarks, as do the well-prepared wings. Beyond the food, the restaurant is noted for its friendly staff and clean environment, enhancing the overall dining experience. Many patrons also express a sense of nostalgia and loyalty, highlighting the brand’s long-standing presence and consistent quality over the years.

Betty Hamm

Jun 16, 2025

Best pizza! No short cuts taken here. All made from scrap. They have the years of experience and know how to do a pizza right. Only mad that I haven't lived here my whole life to enjoy. If you haven't tried then you must. If you do your gonna miss out on some serious good pizza!

Mark Nicastro

Jun 03, 2025

Only a few Pizza Shops in Rochester make Small Pizzas. Tom & Nancy's makes them, thus a perfect dinner for one. Sometimes with leftovers for lunch the next day.

Ed Starowicz

May 06, 2025

Great pizza & wings. Asked for thin crust cheese and pepperoni. The sauce flavor was wonderful. Wings were medium and nicely done.

laura lovestocraft

May 05, 2025

When I was a teenager I had my first apartment on Winchester St. On the corner of Winchester & Dewey Ave was Tom & Nancy's the best pizza ever! That was over 40 yrs ago. My husband and I were so excited to find Tom & Nancy's Pizza recently on Stone Rd. of course we ordered one it was delicious just as my husband & I remembered maybe a little better if that's possible!!

Scott Stewart

Apr 19, 2025

The staff is awesome, the pizza is over the top excellent, very friendly and clean. What else can I say? It is definitely worth checking out